AI Policy

1. Policy Statement

Physical Education and Sports: Studies and Research (PESSR) recognizes the potential of artificial intelligence (AI) and AI-assisted technologies to support scientific research, scholarly writing, editorial processes, and academic communication.

However, the use of these technologies must uphold research integrity, originality, transparency, confidentiality, accountability, and responsible scholarly publishing.

PESSR's AI Policy is informed by the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing, Version 5.0 (2026), the recommendations of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE), and relevant guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the World Association of Medical Editors (WAME).

This policy establishes requirements for the use and disclosure of AI by authors, peer reviewers, editors, and editorial personnel.

AI-assisted technologies may support scholarly activities but must not replace independent scientific judgment, human accountability, or ethical responsibility.

2. Scope and Definition of AI-Assisted Technologies

For the purposes of this policy, AI-assisted technologies include systems that use machine learning, natural language processing, large language models, generative AI, or related computational techniques to generate, analyze, summarize, translate, or modify research-related content.

These technologies may include:

  • Generative AI and large language models, such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, and comparable systems.

  • AI-assisted writing, editing, paraphrasing, and translation tools.

  • AI-based literature discovery, screening, and summarization systems.

  • AI-assisted statistical analysis, programming, and data visualization tools.

  • AI systems used to generate or modify images, figures, tables, and other research materials.

The ethical requirements depend on how a tool is used, its influence on the research or manuscript, and the potential risks to accuracy, originality, confidentiality, and transparency.

The journal distinguishes between conventional automated functions, such as basic spelling correction, and generative or substantive AI-assisted activities that affect scholarly content.

3. Acceptable Use of AI by Authors

PESSR permits responsible use of AI-assisted technologies when their use is transparent, scientifically justified, and subject to appropriate human verification.

Acceptable applications may include:

  • Language improvement: Correcting grammar, spelling, punctuation, and improving linguistic clarity or readability.

  • Translation: Assisting with translation of scholarly text, provided that the authors verify its accuracy, technical terminology, and intended meaning.

  • Literature discovery: Assisting in identifying potentially relevant scholarly literature, provided that all sources and bibliographic details are independently verified.

  • Reference management: Supporting bibliographic formatting and organization without fabricating or misrepresenting references.

  • Data analysis and programming: Assisting with statistical programming, analytical procedures, or computational workflows, provided that the methods and outputs are independently validated and adequately documented.

  • Scientific visualization: Supporting the preparation of legitimate diagrams, illustrations, or visual representations when the resulting material is accurate, appropriately disclosed, and clearly distinguished from original research evidence.

The use of AI must not compromise the originality, scientific validity, or reproducibility of the research.

Authors must retain substantive intellectual control over study design, methodological decisions, data interpretation, scientific arguments, and conclusions.

The use of AI to assist with scientific activities does not remove the requirement to describe research methods accurately or provide sufficient information for independent evaluation.

4. Prohibited and Unacceptable Uses

PESSR prohibits AI-assisted activities that compromise research integrity, misrepresent scientific contributions, or violate ethical and legal obligations.

Unacceptable practices include:

  • Fabricating or falsifying research data, participant information, statistical results, citations, or research findings.

  • Generating fictitious references or citing sources that have not been independently verified.

  • Presenting AI-generated interpretations, analyses, or conclusions as independently established scientific findings without appropriate verification.

  • Using AI-generated material to plagiarize, misappropriate, or inadequately acknowledge existing scholarly work.

  • Manipulating research images or figures in ways that misrepresent original observations or evidence.

  • Presenting synthetic or AI-generated images as authentic photographs, experimental observations, or primary research data.

  • Using AI to impersonate authors, reviewers, editors, research participants, or other individuals.

  • Submitting confidential, identifiable, or sensitive research information to AI services without appropriate authorization and safeguards.

  • Using AI to conceal research misconduct, fabricate peer review, or manipulate the publication process.

AI must not replace the intellectual responsibilities that qualify individuals for authorship.

Substantial AI-generated manuscript content is not acceptable when it substitutes for the authors' scientific reasoning, misrepresents their contributions, or lacks adequate disclosure and independent verification.

5. Authorship and Human Accountability

AI systems, chatbots, and other AI-assisted technologies cannot be listed as authors or co-authors of manuscripts submitted to PESSR.

Authorship is reserved for individuals who meet the journal's authorship criteria and can accept responsibility for the accuracy, originality, integrity, and interpretation of the published work.

Authors remain fully accountable for all submitted content, including material prepared or modified using AI tools.

Authors must:

  • Independently verify the factual and scientific accuracy of AI-assisted content.

  • Check all citations, references, statistical results, and interpretations.

  • Ensure that the manuscript does not contain plagiarism, fabricated information, or misleading representations.

  • Disclose reportable AI use accurately and completely.

  • Ensure compliance with copyright, data protection, and research ethics requirements.

  • Review and approve the final manuscript before submission.

AI-generated outputs must not be cited as authoritative substitutes for original scholarly sources.

Further details are available in the journal's Authorship and Contributorship Policy.

6. Mandatory AI Disclosure by Authors

Authors must disclose the use of generative AI and other AI-assisted technologies that contribute to manuscript content or substantive research activities.

Disclosure is required when AI is used for activities including:

  • Generating, substantially rewriting, or translating manuscript text.

  • Developing research ideas, study designs, or methodological procedures.

  • Producing or assisting with statistical analyses, computer code, or analytical models.

  • Conducting AI-assisted literature screening, evidence extraction, or synthesis.

  • Generating or substantially modifying scientific figures, illustrations, or tables.

  • Supporting the interpretation of results or development of scientific arguments.

Routine use of conventional spelling, punctuation, and basic formatting tools that do not generate or substantially transform scholarly content does not require disclosure.

When there is uncertainty about whether AI use is substantive, authors should disclose it.

6.1. Information Required

AI disclosures must identify:

  1. The name of the AI tool or service used.

  2. The developer or service provider.

  3. The version or model, when identifiable and relevant.

  4. The specific purpose and extent of its use.

  5. The manuscript section or research activity affected.

  6. Confirmation that the authors independently reviewed and verified the AI-assisted outputs and accept responsibility for the final content.

6.2. Location of AI Disclosure

All manuscripts must include a dedicated section titled AI Disclosure Statement.

When reportable AI was used, authors must provide a factual description of its use rather than a general statement that AI was used to improve the manuscript.

When no reportable AI-assisted technologies were used, authors must include the following statement:

"The authors declare that no reportable generative AI or AI-assisted technologies were used in the research or preparation of this manuscript."

When AI contributes to research design, data processing, statistical analysis, coding, or other methodological procedures, the relevant details must also be reported in the Methods section to support transparency and reproducibility.

Authors must disclose reportable AI use at the time of manuscript submission and update the declaration when additional AI assistance is used during revision.

7. AI Use in Research Data, Images, and Scientific Reporting

AI-assisted data processing and analysis must meet the same standards of methodological transparency, validity, and reproducibility as other research methods.

Where AI contributes substantively to research procedures, authors must describe the relevant tools, procedures, validation methods, and limitations.

Authors must distinguish clearly between authentic research evidence and AI-generated illustrative material.

AI-generated illustrations must not be presented as original experimental observations, participant photographs, or measured research results.

Research images must not be manipulated in ways that conceal, fabricate, exaggerate, or misrepresent scientific information.

For studies involving human participants, particularly minors or vulnerable populations, authors must ensure that AI use complies with applicable ethical approvals, informed consent requirements, confidentiality obligations, and data protection standards.

The journal may request supporting documentation when the authenticity, accuracy, or provenance of AI-assisted research material is uncertain.

8. Use of AI by Peer Reviewers

PESSR requires peer reviewers to maintain independent scientific judgment, confidentiality, and professional accountability.

Reviewers must not upload, copy, submit, or disclose any part of an unpublished manuscript or confidential editorial material to generative AI platforms or third-party AI systems.

This restriction includes manuscript text, abstracts, research data, tables, figures, supplementary materials, unpublished findings, and confidential editorial correspondence.

AI-assisted technologies may be used for limited supporting activities that do not involve confidential manuscript information, such as:

  • Improving the readability or linguistic clarity of independently written reviewer comments that contain no confidential material.

  • Conducting general background literature searches using publicly available information.

Reviewers must not delegate manuscript-specific scientific evaluation, methodological assessment, or editorial recommendations to AI systems.

Reviewers who use generative AI or other reportable AI-assisted technologies in preparing their reports must disclose the tool and its purpose to the handling editor.

Routine basic spelling, grammar, and punctuation checks do not require disclosure.

Reviewers remain personally responsible for all comments, recommendations, and scientific assessments submitted to the journal.

Further details are provided in the Guidelines for Reviewers.

9. Use of AI by Editors and Editorial Personnel

PESSR maintains human responsibility and editorial independence throughout manuscript assessment, peer review, and publication decisions.

AI systems must not independently determine manuscript acceptance, rejection, revision requirements, or other substantive editorial decisions.

The Editor-in-Chief and designated handling editors remain accountable for editorial decisions.

AI-assisted technologies may support appropriate administrative or editorial activities only when their use complies with confidentiality, information security, research integrity, and applicable data protection requirements.

Editors and editorial personnel must not upload confidential submitted manuscripts, unpublished research data, or protected editorial correspondence to unauthorized external AI systems.

Any use of AI in manuscript screening, editorial comments, copyediting, or publication production must be subject to human verification and appropriate transparency.

Where AI tools are introduced into substantive editorial or production workflows, the journal must disclose the nature and purpose of such use to affected authors as appropriate.

Editors must not rely exclusively on AI-generated assessments to evaluate scientific validity, research ethics, originality, or methodological quality.

The journal's editorial procedures must preserve confidentiality, fairness, independent judgment, and accountability.

10. AI Detection and Editorial Assessment

PESSR does not apply a fixed maximum percentage of AI-generated text as a condition of manuscript acceptance.

Automated AI-writing detection tools may be used as supplementary indicators during editorial assessment, but their outputs are not considered conclusive evidence of AI use or research misconduct.

AI-writing detection results must be distinguished from text similarity reports used for plagiarism screening.

A manuscript must not be rejected, corrected, or retracted solely because an automated AI detector reports a particular percentage or classification.

Where concerns arise, editors may:

  1. Examine the manuscript for factual inaccuracies, fabricated references, methodological inconsistencies, or other substantive concerns.

  2. Review the author's AI Disclosure Statement.

  3. Request clarification regarding the tools and procedures used.

  4. Request relevant supporting documentation when justified.

  5. Evaluate the author's explanation before determining appropriate editorial action.

All assessments must involve human judgment and comply with the journal's publication ethics and editorial procedures.

11. Non-Compliance, Corrections, and Appeals

Suspected violations of this policy will be assessed fairly, confidentially, and proportionately.

Non-disclosure of AI use does not automatically establish research misconduct. The Editorial Office will consider the nature, extent, and consequences of the omission, including whether the research record has been misrepresented.

Depending on the circumstances, appropriate actions may include:

  • Requesting clarification or an updated AI Disclosure Statement.

  • Requesting revisions or additional supporting information.

  • Rejecting a manuscript where serious concerns remain unresolved.

  • Investigating suspected fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, or other research misconduct.

  • Publishing a correction or other appropriate notice when post-publication disclosure or clarification is necessary.

  • Issuing an expression of concern or retracting an article when justified by serious concerns affecting the integrity or reliability of the published record.

  • Contacting relevant institutions when an institutional investigation is warranted.

Editorial actions must be based on documented evidence and relevant publication ethics principles.

Authors will ordinarily be provided with an opportunity to respond to concerns before a final misconduct-related determination is made.

Authors may request reconsideration of editorial decisions through the journal's Complaints and Appeals Policy.

12. Policy Implementation and Review

PESSR will periodically review its AI Policy to reflect developments in artificial intelligence, research integrity, data protection, and scholarly publishing standards.

Authors, reviewers, editors, and editorial personnel are expected to comply with the requirements relevant to their roles.

The journal encourages the responsible use of emerging technologies while maintaining transparency, independent scientific judgment, and accountability for published research.

Questions concerning the interpretation or implementation of this policy may be directed to the Editorial Office at support@rezkimedia.or.id.

13. References and Ethical Guidance

  1. COPE, DOAJ, OASPA, and WAME. (2026). Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing, Version 5.0.

  2. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. (2026). Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals.

  3. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Use of AI by Authors.

  4. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Use of AI by Reviewers.

  5. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Editors' Role in Ensuring Responsible Use of AI.

  6. World Association of Medical Editors. Chatbots, Generative AI, and Scholarly Manuscripts: WAME Recommendations.

  7. Committee on Publication Ethics. Authorship and AI Tools.

  8. Turnitin. Using the AI Writing Report.