Plagiarism Policy

1. Policy Statement

Physical Education and Sports: Studies and Research (PESSR) is committed to maintaining originality, academic integrity, and transparency in scholarly publishing. The journal prohibits plagiarism, inappropriate text recycling, redundant publication, and other forms of misrepresentation of previously published work.

PESSR's plagiarism prevention and investigation procedures are informed by the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing, Version 5.0 (2026) and relevant guidance issued by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

All manuscripts are subject to originality screening and editorial assessment. Authors are responsible for ensuring that their submissions are original, appropriately attributed, and compliant with the journal's publication ethics requirements.

2. Definition and Types of Plagiarism

Plagiarism occurs when an individual presents another person's words, ideas, data, research findings, or other intellectual contributions as their own without appropriate acknowledgment.

PESSR recognizes the following forms of plagiarism and related publication integrity concerns:

  • Direct Plagiarism: Reproducing another person's text or substantial portions of published material without appropriate quotation and attribution.

  • Paraphrasing Plagiarism: Rewording another person's ideas, arguments, or findings without proper acknowledgment.

  • Data and Figure Plagiarism: Presenting another person's datasets, tables, figures, images, or research results without appropriate attribution or necessary permission.

  • Idea Plagiarism: Presenting another researcher's original concepts, hypotheses, interpretations, or methodological contributions as one's own.

  • Self-Plagiarism and Inappropriate Text Recycling: Reusing substantial portions of one's previously published work without appropriate disclosure, citation, or scientific justification.

  • Redundant or Duplicate Publication: Publishing substantially overlapping research findings or datasets as separate original publications without adequate disclosure, cross-referencing, or justification.

The journal distinguishes between deliberate misappropriation, inappropriate reuse, legitimate methodological overlap, and minor attribution errors.

Properly acknowledged reuse of material may be acceptable under applicable copyright, licensing, and editorial requirements.

3. Originality and Previous Publication

Manuscripts submitted to PESSR must represent original scholarly contributions and must not be under simultaneous consideration by another journal.

Authors must disclose any closely related publications, previous dissemination, or overlapping manuscripts, including:

  • Preprints deposited in public repositories.

  • Conference papers or proceedings.

  • Previously published articles derived from the same dataset.

  • Translations or adaptations of previously published research.

  • Related manuscripts submitted to or published by other journals.

The existence of a preprint does not automatically constitute duplicate publication. PESSR may consider manuscripts previously posted as preprints when prior dissemination is transparently disclosed and the submission otherwise complies with the journal's policies.

Previously published work, including translations, must not be presented as a new original publication without appropriate editorial authorization, acknowledgment, and compliance with applicable rights.

Reuse of methodological descriptions may be acceptable when adequately attributed and scientifically justified. Undisclosed duplication of research findings or substantial reuse that misrepresents the originality of a study is unacceptable.

4. Similarity Screening and Editorial Assessment

PESSR uses iThenticate to screen manuscripts for textual similarity as part of its editorial assessment.

The journal applies a 15% overall similarity screening benchmark, assessed after appropriate exclusion of reference lists and properly attributed quotations.

The following principles apply:

  • Manuscripts with similarity scores exceeding 15% are subject to closer editorial examination and may be returned to authors for clarification or revision.

  • A similarity score exceeding 15% does not automatically establish plagiarism or result in rejection.

  • Manuscripts with similarity scores of 15% or lower may still contain plagiarism and remain subject to editorial assessment.

  • Significant unattributed overlap with a single source, particularly involving original ideas, data, or findings, may warrant investigation regardless of the overall similarity percentage.

  • Similarity reports must be interpreted by qualified editorial personnel rather than used as the sole basis for determining misconduct.

Where appropriate, the journal may exclude bibliographies and properly attributed quotations from similarity calculations. Additional exclusions must be applied consistently and should not conceal substantial or problematic overlap.

Editors will assess the location, extent, context, attribution, and significance of identified similarities.

The similarity score is an editorial screening indicator, not a definitive measurement of plagiarism.

5. Handling Suspected Plagiarism Before Publication

When potential plagiarism is identified in a submitted manuscript, the Editorial Office will assess the available evidence before determining appropriate action.

The process may include:

  1. Examining the similarity report and the original sources of matching content.

  2. Determining the nature and extent of the overlap.

  3. Requesting clarification or supporting documentation from the corresponding author.

  4. Evaluating the author's explanation and any submitted revisions.

  5. Consulting independent experts or relevant institutions when necessary.

  6. Recording the findings and determining an appropriate editorial outcome.

Depending on the severity and circumstances, editorial actions may include:

  • Minor attribution errors: Requesting correction, proper citation, or revision before further consideration.

  • Inappropriate text recycling or substantial overlap: Requesting clarification or revision, or rejecting the manuscript when originality is insufficient.

  • Serious plagiarism or deliberate misrepresentation: Rejecting the manuscript and considering notification of the authors' institutions when warranted.

Authors will ordinarily be provided with an opportunity to respond to documented concerns before a final misconduct-related determination is made.

The Editor-in-Chief retains responsibility for final editorial decisions.

6. Handling Plagiarism After Publication

Allegations of plagiarism involving published articles will be investigated in accordance with relevant COPE guidance and the journal's publication ethics procedures.

The Editorial Office may examine the original sources, request explanations from the authors, consult independent experts, and communicate with relevant institutions when appropriate.

Editorial actions will be proportionate to the nature and seriousness of the confirmed concerns.

Possible outcomes include:

  • No further action: When the allegation is unsupported or the overlap is legitimate.

  • Correction: When limited unattributed material or citation errors can be corrected without undermining the article's central findings or scholarly contribution.

  • Expression of Concern: When serious unresolved concerns warrant informing readers while an investigation continues.

  • Retraction: When substantial plagiarism, redundant publication, or other serious integrity concerns undermine the reliability or legitimacy of the published work.

A finding of plagiarism does not automatically require retraction in every case. Decisions must consider the extent and significance of the material involved and the integrity of the scholarly record.

Retraction notices and corrections will be publicly accessible, clearly explain the editorial action, and be linked to the original article.

Further details are provided in the journal's Post-Publication Discussions and Corrections Policy and Retraction and Correction Policy.

7. Responsibilities of Authors and Editors

Authors must:

  • Submit original research and appropriately acknowledge all sources.

  • Disclose related publications, preprints, and overlapping material.

  • Obtain necessary permissions for reused copyrighted content.

  • Ensure the accuracy and transparency of citations, figures, data, and research reports.

  • Respond appropriately to editorial concerns regarding originality or attribution.

  • Comply with the journal's AI Policy when using generative AI or AI-assisted technologies.

Editors must:

  • Conduct or oversee appropriate originality screening.

  • Evaluate similarity reports using informed human judgment.

  • Avoid treating similarity percentages as conclusive evidence of misconduct.

  • Apply the journal's policies fairly and consistently.

  • Maintain confidentiality during investigations.

  • Document findings and communicate editorial decisions appropriately.

  • Follow relevant COPE guidance when addressing suspected plagiarism or redundant publication.

The use of generative AI does not, by itself, constitute plagiarism. However, AI-assisted content that misappropriates existing work, fabricates citations, or misrepresents originality may raise publication integrity concerns.

8. Reporting Concerns and Appeals

PESSR welcomes evidence-based reports of suspected plagiarism or redundant publication from authors, reviewers, readers, institutions, and other stakeholders.

Reports should identify the publication or manuscript concerned and provide sufficient information to support an initial assessment.

Concerns may be submitted through the journal's Ethical Concern Reporting Form.

Reports will be assessed fairly and confidentially, subject to applicable legal and ethical obligations.

Authors who believe an editorial decision resulted from a procedural error or a significant misunderstanding may seek reconsideration through the journal's Complaints and Appeals Policy.

9. Policy Implementation and Review

PESSR will periodically review its plagiarism prevention and investigation procedures to maintain consistency with developments in research integrity, scholarly publishing, and international publication ethics guidance.

Similarity screening supports editorial judgment but does not replace independent evaluation of originality and research integrity.

The journal is committed to applying this policy consistently while ensuring fairness, transparency, and appropriate procedural safeguards.

10. References and Ethical Guidance

  1. COPE, DOAJ, OASPA, and WAME. (2026). Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing, Version 5.0.

  2. Committee on Publication Ethics. Plagiarism in a Submitted Manuscript.

  3. Committee on Publication Ethics. Plagiarism in a Published Article.

  4. Committee on Publication Ethics. Text Recycling Guidelines for Editors.

  5. Committee on Publication Ethics. Retraction Guidelines.

  6. Committee on Publication Ethics. Redundant Publication in a Published Article.

  7. iThenticate. Understanding the Similarity Report.