Peer Review Process
1. Policy Statement
Physical Education and Sports: Studies and Research (PESSR) is committed to maintaining a rigorous, fair, transparent, and independent peer-review process to ensure the scientific quality and integrity of published research.
The journal follows the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing, Version 5.0 (2026), particularly Principles 8 and 9 concerning editorial assessment and peer review.
2. Initial Editorial Assessment
All submitted manuscripts undergo an initial assessment by the Editor-in-Chief or a designated editor to evaluate their relevance to the journal's scope, originality, scientific contribution, methodological quality, and compliance with submission and ethical requirements.
Manuscripts that do not meet these requirements may be rejected without external peer review (desk rejection).
Manuscripts that pass the initial assessment proceed to independent peer review.
Editorial decisions are based on scholarly merit and remain independent of financial, institutional, or other inappropriate external influences.
3. Double-Anonymized Peer Review
PESSR employs a double-anonymized peer-review process, in which authors' identities are concealed from reviewers and reviewers' identities are concealed from authors.
Manuscripts that pass initial screening are normally evaluated by at least two independent external reviewers with expertise relevant to the manuscript's subject matter or methodology.
Reviewers are selected by the handling editor based on their academic expertise, independence, and absence of significant conflicts of interest.
Reviewers must maintain manuscript confidentiality, provide objective assessments, and must not contact authors directly or involve other individuals in the review without editorial authorization.
Reviewer reports and identities are treated as confidential and are not routinely published alongside articles.
Reviewers must comply with the journal's Guidelines for Reviewers, Conflict of Interest Policy, and AI Policy.
Reviewer Selection and Author Recommendations
Reviewers are independently selected and appointed by the handling editor based on their subject expertise, methodological competence, independence, and absence of significant conflicts of interest.
Authors are not required to recommend reviewers. Any reviewer recommendations submitted by authors may be considered at the editor's discretion but do not guarantee an invitation. The editor independently verifies the suitability and independence of potential reviewers and retains full authority over reviewer selection.
Peer Review Timeline
Reviewers are assigned specific deadlines through the journal's editorial system. The time required for peer review may vary depending on reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, the number of review rounds, and the extent of revisions.
PESSR aims to conduct peer review efficiently while maintaining rigorous scientific evaluation. The journal normally estimates approximately two to three months from submission to publication. This represents the overall publication process rather than the duration of external peer review alone.
Authors may contact the Editorial Office for updates on the progress of their manuscripts. The journal does not guarantee a fixed review or publication timeframe.
Review of Supplementary Materials
Supplementary materials relevant to the scientific evaluation of a manuscript may be provided to reviewers as part of the peer-review process.
These materials may include research protocols, reporting checklists, supplementary datasets, statistical analysis files, research instruments, and additional methodological documentation.
Reviewers are expected to consider relevant supplementary materials when evaluating the transparency, methodological rigor, and reproducibility of the research.
Confidential administrative documents, including ethics approval certificates and identifiable participant information, are handled separately by the Editorial Office and are not routinely shared with external reviewers.
All supplementary materials provided for peer review remain subject to the journal's confidentiality and research integrity requirements.
4. Review Criteria and Recommendations
Reviewers evaluate manuscripts based on:
-
Originality, novelty, and scientific contribution.
-
Relevance to physical education, sport sciences, and related disciplines.
-
Appropriateness of research design and methodology.
-
Validity of statistical analysis and interpretation.
-
Clarity and accuracy of results and conclusions.
-
Adequacy of references, reporting standards, and research ethics compliance.
Reviewers may recommend:
-
Accept: The manuscript meets publication requirements without substantial revision.
-
Minor Revision: Limited improvements are required.
-
Major Revision: Substantial revisions are necessary before further consideration.
-
Reject: The manuscript does not meet the journal's scientific or publication requirements.
Reviewers provide recommendations, not final editorial decisions.
Detailed evaluation criteria and reporting procedures are provided in the Guidelines for Reviewers.
5. Manuscript Revision and Re-Review
Authors invited to revise their manuscripts must:
-
Address reviewers' and editors' comments systematically.
-
Submit a separate point-by-point response to reviewers.
-
Highlight all changes in the revised manuscript without using tracked changes.
Revised manuscripts may undergo additional evaluation by the original reviewers, new independent reviewers, or the handling editor, depending on the extent of the revisions and unresolved scientific concerns.
An invitation to revise does not guarantee acceptance.
6. Editorial Decisions
Editorial decisions are based on reviewer recommendations, scientific merit, methodological rigor, ethical compliance, and the journal's publication standards.
The Editor-in-Chief retains ultimate responsibility for editorial decisions, including those delegated to handling editors.
When reviewer recommendations differ substantially, the editor may seek additional independent assessments.
Decisions are communicated to authors through the journal's editorial system.
Authors who believe a decision involves substantial procedural errors or bias may refer to the Complaints and Appeals Policy.
7. Review Timeline and Publication
PESSR is committed to conducting a timely, rigorous, and transparent editorial and peer-review process.
The peer-review process typically takes approximately 4–6 weeks, depending on reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, and the need for additional assessments.
The average time from manuscript submission to publication is approximately 2–3 months, including initial editorial assessment, peer review, author revisions, editorial decisions, copyediting, and production.
These timelines are estimates rather than guaranteed deadlines. Manuscripts requiring substantial revisions or additional review rounds may take longer.
Authors will be informed of substantial delays where appropriate and may contact the Editorial Office to inquire about the status of their submissions.
Following acceptance, authors will receive article proofs and are expected to return corrections within 14 working days.
Further manuscript preparation and submission requirements are available in the Author Guidelines.
8. References
-
COPE, DOAJ, OASPA, and WAME. (2026). Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing, Version 5.0.
-
Committee on Publication Ethics. Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers.
-
Committee on Publication Ethics. Peer Review Models.












