Publication Ethics
1. Commitment to Publication Ethics
Physical Education and Sports: Studies and Research (PESSR), published by CV. Rezki Media, is committed to maintaining integrity, transparency, accountability, and ethical conduct throughout the research evaluation and publication process.
PESSR's editorial practices are informed by the following internationally recognized standards:
-
Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing, Version 5.0 (2026), developed jointly by COPE, DOAJ, OASPA, and WAME.
-
Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) – Guidance and Resources.
-
International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) – Recommendations (2026).
-
World Medical Association – Declaration of Helsinki (2024), where applicable to research involving human participants.
These principles apply to all scholarly content published in the regular issues of Physical Education and Sports: Studies and Research (PESSR).
PESSR expects authors, reviewers, editors, editorial board members, and the publisher to comply with the journal's publication ethics policies.
2. Responsibilities of Authors
Authors are responsible for ensuring the originality, accuracy, transparency, and ethical integrity of their submitted and published work.
Authors must:
-
Submit original manuscripts that are not simultaneously under consideration by another journal.
-
Report research methods, data, analyses, and findings accurately, without fabrication, falsification, or inappropriate manipulation.
-
Properly acknowledge previous research and disclose any related publications, preprints, or overlapping content.
-
Meet the journal's authorship criteria and accurately declare individual contributions.
-
Disclose all funding sources, financial support, and potential conflicts of interest.
-
Obtain appropriate research ethics approval, documented exemption, and participant consent where applicable.
-
Comply with clinical trial registration requirements when their research meets the applicable definition.
-
Provide accurate data availability and AI-use disclosure statements.
-
Cooperate with editorial inquiries, requests for research documentation, and post-publication investigations.
-
Promptly notify the Editorial Office of significant errors or ethical concerns affecting their work.
All listed authors must approve the manuscript submitted for consideration and accept accountability for their contributions.
Further information is provided in the Authorship and Contributorship Policy.
3. Responsibilities of Reviewers
Peer reviewers are expected to provide independent, objective, constructive, and timely evaluations based on scientific merit.
Reviewers must:
-
Maintain the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and editorial correspondence.
-
Disclose actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest before accepting review assignments.
-
Evaluate manuscripts without discrimination or inappropriate personal influence.
-
Refrain from using unpublished information, data, or ideas for personal or professional advantage.
-
Avoid inappropriate citation requests and attempts to manipulate editorial decisions.
-
Notify the handling editor of suspected ethical concerns, including plagiarism, duplicate publication, data manipulation, or irregularities in ethical approval.
-
Comply with the journal's restrictions and disclosure requirements concerning artificial intelligence.
Confidential manuscript materials must not be uploaded to unauthorized third-party AI systems. Reviewers remain personally responsible for the scientific evaluation and recommendations they provide.
Reviewers provide recommendations; final editorial decisions remain the responsibility of the journal's editors.
Further details are available in the Guidelines for Reviewers.
4. Responsibilities of Editors and Editorial Independence
Editors are responsible for ensuring that manuscripts are evaluated fairly, confidentially, independently, and consistently with the journal's policies.
Editorial decisions must be based on scholarly merit, originality, methodological rigor, research integrity, and relevance to the journal's aims and scope.
Editorial decisions must not be influenced by:
-
Authors' nationality, ethnicity, gender, religion, political beliefs, institutional affiliation, or professional status.
-
Commercial interests, sponsorship, institutional pressure, or inappropriate external influence.
-
Authors' ability to pay Article Processing Charges (APCs) or eligibility for fee waivers.
-
Personal relationships or undisclosed conflicts of interest.
The Editor-in-Chief retains final responsibility for acceptance and rejection decisions, including decisions informed by delegated editorial assessments.
Editors involved in individual manuscript decisions must not participate in administering article-level payments or fee waivers for those manuscripts.
Editors must recuse themselves from handling manuscripts where significant conflicts of interest exist. An appropriate independent editor will be assigned where necessary.
The journal does not use artificial intelligence to make autonomous editorial decisions. Any AI-assisted editorial activity must comply with the journal's AI Policy and remain subject to human oversight.
5. Editorial Assessment and Peer Review Integrity
All submitted manuscripts undergo an initial editorial assessment to determine their suitability for peer review.
Manuscripts may be rejected without external peer review when they fall outside the journal's scope, fail to meet submission or ethical requirements, lack sufficient scholarly contribution, or contain significant methodological deficiencies.
Research manuscripts that pass initial screening normally undergo double-anonymized peer review by at least two independent experts.
The editorial assessment and peer review process must be conducted without manipulation, fabricated reviewer identities, undisclosed conflicts of interest, or inappropriate attempts to influence editorial outcomes.
The journal does not guarantee acceptance of submitted manuscripts. Any exception to the journal's normal peer review arrangements must be transparently disclosed.
Further details are available in the Peer Review Process.
6. Authorship, Contributorship, and Artificial Intelligence
Authorship must reflect genuine intellectual contributions and accountability for the published work.
PESSR prohibits guest, gift, honorary, and ghost authorship. Authorship changes require appropriate justification and the agreement of relevant contributors, in accordance with the journal's authorship policy.
Artificial intelligence tools cannot be listed as authors because they cannot assume responsibility or accountability for published research.
Authors must disclose the use of generative AI and AI-assisted technologies in manuscript preparation or research activities as required by the journal's AI Policy. Disclosures must identify the tool and explain its purpose and extent of use.
This includes relevant use in study design, data analysis, manuscript drafting, translation, image generation, and other substantive research or writing activities.
Authors remain responsible for verifying all AI-assisted content, including citations, statistical outputs, figures, and interpretations.
Editors and reviewers must also comply with applicable AI-use disclosure and confidentiality requirements.
Further details are available in the AI Policy.
7. Research Ethics and Participant Protection
Research involving human participants must comply with applicable ethical regulations, institutional requirements, and internationally recognized ethical principles, including the Declaration of Helsinki (2024) where relevant.
Authors must provide:
-
The name of the approving Research Ethics Committee or Institutional Review Board.
-
The ethics approval reference number and approval date, where applicable.
-
Confirmation that informed consent was obtained or appropriately waived by an authorized ethics body.
-
Information on additional safeguards for vulnerable participants.
Research involving minors must obtain appropriate parental or legally authorized representative consent and, where applicable, age-appropriate participant assent.
When an exemption from ethics review applies, authors must provide appropriate documentation from an authorized ethics committee or institution. Authors must not independently assume that their research is exempt without an adequate basis.
Studies involving identifiable photographs, videos, personal information, or other potentially identifying material must obtain specific consent for publication where required.
PESSR may request supporting documentation and consult relevant ethics committees or institutions when ethical compliance is uncertain.
Further details are provided in the Ethical Clearance Policy.
8. Clinical Trial Registration
PESSR requires prospective registration of eligible clinical trials in accordance with its Clinical Trial Registration Policy, informed by ICMJE and WHO standards.
Studies prospectively assigning individuals or groups to health-related interventions for the purpose of evaluating health-related outcomes may qualify as clinical trials, regardless of whether the design is randomized.
Authors must disclose the trial registry, registration number, registration date, and date of first participant enrollment, as applicable.
Ethics committee approval does not replace prospective clinical trial registration.
Unregistered or retrospectively registered trials are handled according to the journal's specific registration policy. Any exceptional editorial consideration must be documented and transparently disclosed.
Concerns involving previously published articles will be assessed individually, taking account of the applicable requirements at the time of submission and the reliability of the published findings.
See the Clinical Trial Registration Policy.
9. Plagiarism, Redundant Publication, and Research Misconduct
PESSR prohibits research and publication misconduct, including:
-
Plagiarism and misappropriation of others' words, ideas, data, or research outputs.
-
Undisclosed self-plagiarism, inappropriate text recycling, and redundant or overlapping publication.
-
Fabrication or falsification of data, methods, or results.
-
Inappropriate manipulation of figures, images, or research records.
-
Citation manipulation and coercive citation practices.
-
Peer review manipulation or fraudulent reviewer identities.
-
Misrepresentation of authorship, ethical approval, trial registration, or research documentation.
-
Concealment of significant competing interests.
-
Inappropriate or undisclosed use of artificial intelligence.
Authors must disclose any preprints, translations, conference publications, or related manuscripts that substantially overlap with a submission.
A disclosed preprint is not automatically treated as duplicate publication. Its eligibility is evaluated under the journal's applicable policies.
Text similarity screening may be used to identify potential overlap. Similarity scores alone do not establish plagiarism; editorial assessment must consider the context, extent, attribution, and nature of the similarity.
Further details are available in the Plagiarism Policy.
10. Conflicts of Interest and Funding Disclosure
All authors, reviewers, editors, editorial board members, and relevant publishing personnel must disclose actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest that could compromise, or appear to compromise, objective research evaluation and publication.
These may include financial, institutional, academic, professional, personal, political, or other competing interests.
Conflicts must be disclosed at the relevant stage of manuscript submission or handling, and any newly identified conflicts must be reported promptly.
Significant editorial or reviewer conflicts must be managed through recusal and appropriate reassignment.
Authors must disclose all sources of financial and non-financial support, including grants, equipment, materials, services, and other assistance related to the research or preparation of the manuscript.
When no funding was received, authors must explicitly state:
"No funding was received for this study."
Undisclosed competing interests or funding arrangements may require clarification, correction, or further editorial investigation.
See the Conflict of Interest Policy.
11. Data Sharing and Research Reproducibility
PESSR supports transparent research reporting, responsible data sharing, and reproducibility.
Authors must provide a Data Availability Statement identifying how and under what conditions the data supporting their findings can be accessed.
Where ethically and legally permissible, authors are encouraged to deposit research datasets, analytical code, study protocols, and other supporting materials in recognized repositories.
Restrictions involving participant privacy, sensitive information, confidentiality agreements, or legal requirements must be clearly explained.
Authors must accurately describe their methods and follow appropriate reporting guidelines for their study design.
See the Data and Reproducibility Policy.
12. Handling Allegations of Research and Publication Misconduct
PESSR takes allegations of misconduct seriously, whether raised before or after publication.
All concerns will be assessed fairly, impartially, and confidentially, with due consideration for the rights and responsibilities of all parties involved.
The Editorial Office will generally:
-
Record the allegation and assess whether sufficient information or evidence is available for preliminary evaluation.
-
Review relevant manuscript files, research documentation, and editorial correspondence.
-
Request clarification or supporting evidence from the individuals concerned, where appropriate.
-
Seek independent expert advice or contact relevant institutions or ethics committees when necessary.
-
Evaluate the available evidence before determining appropriate editorial action.
-
Document the process and communicate relevant outcomes to the parties involved, subject to confidentiality requirements.
Anonymous or confidential reports may be considered when they contain sufficiently specific and credible information.
PESSR does not presume misconduct solely because an allegation has been made. Individuals concerned will ordinarily be given an appropriate opportunity to respond.
Where institutional investigation is necessary, the journal may coordinate with the relevant institution while retaining responsibility for the integrity of its published record.
Further procedures are described in the Allegations of Misconduct Policy.
13. Corrections, Retractions, and Expressions of Concern
PESSR is committed to preserving the accuracy, reliability, and transparency of the scholarly record.
Depending on the evidence and severity of an identified concern, editorial action may include:
-
Correction: To address errors that require amendment but do not invalidate the article's central findings.
-
Expression of Concern: To alert readers to serious unresolved concerns regarding the integrity or reliability of published research.
-
Retraction: When findings are unreliable or when serious ethical or publication integrity concerns justify withdrawal of the article from the reliable scholarly record.
Post-publication actions must follow relevant COPE guidance, be clearly explained, and be linked to the original article.
Retraction notices must distinguish between honest errors and misconduct where the evidence permits.
Retracted articles should ordinarily remain accessible with clear identification of their retracted status, preserving the transparency of the scholarly record.
Further details are available in the Post-Publication Discussions and Corrections Policy.
14. Complaints, Appeals, and Post-Publication Discussion
PESSR provides mechanisms for authors, reviewers, readers, and other stakeholders to raise complaints about journal procedures, editorial conduct, or publication practices.
Authors may appeal editorial decisions when there is credible evidence of a significant procedural error, factual misunderstanding, bias, or other substantial grounds for reconsideration.
Complaints and appeals will be handled impartially and with appropriate confidentiality. Where an editor has a significant conflict of interest, an independent individual will be assigned to assess the matter.
PESSR also welcomes evidence-based scholarly critiques and discussions of published research.
Further information is available in the Complaints and Appeals Policy.
15. Reporting Ethical Concerns
PESSR welcomes good-faith reports of suspected research or publication misconduct from authors, reviewers, readers, institutions, and other stakeholders.
Reports may involve ethical approval, participant protection, plagiarism, duplicate publication, unreliable data, authorship disputes, peer review manipulation, conflicts of interest, or other concerns affecting the integrity of published research.
Concerns may be submitted through the journal's:
Ethical Concern Reporting Form
Alternatively, concerns may be addressed to:
Editorial Office
Physical Education and Sports: Studies and Research (PESSR)
Publisher: CV. Rezki Media
Email: support@rezkimedia.or.id
Website: https://journal.rezkimedia.or.id/pes/
Reports should contain sufficient details and supporting evidence to enable a meaningful preliminary assessment.
PESSR will protect the confidentiality of individuals raising concerns to the extent reasonably possible and will not tolerate retaliation for good-faith reporting.
All allegations will be handled in accordance with the journal's established procedures and relevant COPE guidance.
16. Policy Implementation and Review
PESSR will periodically review its publication ethics policies to reflect developments in scholarly publishing standards, research integrity, and editorial practice.
The Editor-in-Chief and publisher share responsibility for ensuring that published policies are supported by appropriate editorial procedures, documentation, and oversight.
Any substantive policy revisions will be made publicly accessible through the journal website.
References and Ethical Frameworks
-
COPE, DOAJ, OASPA, and WAME. (2026). Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing (Version 5.0).
-
Committee on Publication Ethics. COPE Guidance and Resources.
-
International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. (2026). Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals.
-
World Medical Association. (2024). Declaration of Helsinki: Ethical Principles for Medical Research Involving Human Participants.
-
International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Clinical Trial Registration.
-
World Health Organization. International Clinical Trials Registry Platform.












