Guidelines for Reviewers

1. Peer Review Principles

Physical Education and Sports: Studies and Research (PESSR) recognizes peer review as an essential process for maintaining scientific quality, research integrity, and editorial independence.

PESSR applies a double-anonymized peer-review process, in which the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from one another. Manuscripts that pass initial editorial assessment are normally evaluated by at least two independent expert reviewers.

Reviewers are expected to provide objective, constructive, evidence-based, and timely assessments. Their recommendations inform editorial decisions, while final responsibility for manuscript acceptance or rejection rests with the journal's editors.

Further information is available in the Peer Review Process.

2. Responsibilities Before Accepting a Review

Before accepting a review invitation, reviewers must ensure that:

  • The manuscript falls within their scientific or methodological expertise.

  • They can provide an independent and impartial evaluation.

  • They can complete the review within the deadline specified in the invitation.

  • They have disclosed any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest.

Reviewers should promptly decline invitations when they lack sufficient expertise, have significant competing interests, or cannot meet the agreed deadline.

Reviewers must not delegate their responsibilities or involve colleagues, students, or other individuals without prior permission from the handling editor.

Further requirements are provided in the Conflict of Interest Policy.

3. Confidentiality and Professional Conduct

All submitted manuscripts, supplementary materials, and editorial communications must be treated as confidential.

Reviewers must not:

  • Disclose or share unpublished manuscript content without editorial authorization.

  • Use unpublished research findings, data, or ideas for personal or professional advantage.

  • Contact authors directly regarding manuscripts under review.

  • Attempt to identify authors whose identities have been anonymized.

  • Retain or distribute confidential manuscript copies beyond what is required for the authorized review process.

If a reviewer's identity becomes known or the author is inadvertently identified, the reviewer should inform the handling editor when this creates a potential conflict or affects impartiality.

Reviewers must provide respectful, professional, and scientifically justified comments. Personal criticism, discriminatory language, coercive citation requests, and unsupported allegations are unacceptable.

Confidentiality obligations continue after the review is completed.

4. Scientific Evaluation Criteria

Reviewers should assess manuscripts according to their research design, scholarly contribution, methodological quality, and relevance to the journal's scope.

The following criteria should guide the assessment:

  1. Originality and significance: Does the manuscript provide a meaningful contribution to existing knowledge?

  2. Relevance: Is the research consistent with the journal's aims and scope?

  3. Title and abstract: Do they accurately represent the objectives, methods, findings, and conclusions?

  4. Introduction: Are the research rationale, knowledge gap, and objectives adequately established?

  5. Methodology: Are the research design, sampling, instruments, procedures, and interventions appropriate and sufficiently described?

  6. Data analysis: Are the analytical methods appropriate, transparently reported, and correctly interpreted?

  7. Results: Are findings presented accurately and consistently, with appropriate tables and figures?

  8. Discussion and conclusions: Are interpretations supported by the evidence, with relevant limitations adequately considered?

  9. References and reporting standards: Are references appropriate and verifiable, and are relevant reporting guidelines followed?

  10. Research integrity: Are ethical approval, participant consent, registration, data availability, and other relevant disclosures adequately reported?

Evaluation criteria must be applied appropriately to the manuscript type.

For systematic reviews and meta-analyses, reviewers should assess search strategies, eligibility criteria, study selection, risk-of-bias assessment, and evidence synthesis.

For experimental and intervention studies, reviewers should examine participant allocation, intervention protocols, outcome measurement, statistical analysis, and relevant participant safety considerations.

5. Research Ethics and Integrity Assessment

Reviewers should consider whether studies involving human participants adequately report ethical approval or documented exemption, informed consent, confidentiality, and appropriate safeguards for vulnerable participants, including children and adolescents.

For studies potentially meeting the ICMJE definition of a clinical trial, reviewers should examine whether prospective registration information is reported and consistent with the study design and outcomes.

Not every exercise intervention or sports performance study automatically qualifies as a clinical trial. Reviewers should consider the applicable definition and refer uncertainties to the handling editor.

Reviewers should also consider the completeness of Data Availability Statements and relevant reporting documentation.

Suspected plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification, duplicate publication, inappropriate image manipulation, misleading ethical declarations, or other integrity concerns must be reported confidentially to the editor.

Reviewers must not independently contact authors or their institutions to investigate suspected misconduct.

Further requirements are provided in the:

6. Use of Generative AI in Peer Review

Peer review requires independent human scientific judgment and professional accountability.

6.1. Confidentiality Restrictions

Reviewers must not upload, copy, submit, or disclose confidential manuscript materials to generative AI platforms or third-party AI systems.

This prohibition includes manuscript text, abstracts, figures, tables, unpublished data, supplementary materials, confidential editorial correspondence, and review comments containing confidential manuscript information.

Claims of privacy protection by an AI service do not independently authorize disclosure of manuscript materials.

6.2. Limited Permitted Uses

AI-assisted technologies may be used for limited supporting activities that do not involve confidential manuscript information, such as:

  • Basic spelling, grammar, and punctuation correction.

  • Improving the readability of independently written text that contains no confidential manuscript information.

  • General literature searches using publicly available information.

Reviewers must not use AI to replace their own scientific assessment, evaluate confidential manuscript content, generate manuscript-specific assessments from confidential materials, or determine editorial recommendations.

6.3. AI Disclosure and Accountability

Reviewers who use generative AI or other reportable AI-assisted technologies in preparing their review reports must disclose the tool and its specific purpose to the handling editor.

Routine spelling, grammar, and punctuation checks that do not substantively generate or transform content do not require disclosure.

AI disclosures must not reveal confidential manuscript information.

Reviewers remain fully responsible for the accuracy, independence, and scientific validity of their evaluations.

Further requirements are provided in the AI Policy.

7. Preparing the Review Report

Reviewers should provide a balanced assessment of the manuscript's strengths, limitations, and required improvements.

Comments to Authors

Comments should be specific, constructive, and supported by scientific reasoning. Major concerns should address issues affecting methodological validity, interpretation, reproducibility, or scientific contribution.

Minor comments may address clarity, organization, terminology, presentation, or other issues that do not substantially affect the principal findings.

Reviewers should identify relevant sections, tables, figures, or line numbers where possible.

Confidential Comments to the Editor

Confidential comments may address significant ethical concerns, competing interests, or other matters requiring editorial attention.

Substantive scientific criticisms that authors need to address should ordinarily also be communicated in the comments intended for authors.

Reviewer Recommendations

Reviewers may recommend:

  • Accept

  • Minor Revision

  • Major Revision

  • Reject

Recommendations must be supported by a clear scientific rationale.

Reviewers should distinguish between problems that can reasonably be addressed through revision and fundamental limitations that undermine the validity or contribution of the manuscript.

The editor retains responsibility for the final decision.

8. Reviewer Form and Submission

Reviewers must complete the journal's review requirements and submit their evaluations through the designated editorial system within the agreed deadline.

Download the PESSR Reviewer Form

The review report should include an overall assessment, major and minor comments, and an editorial recommendation.

Reviewers who anticipate delays should notify the handling editor promptly.

Additional clarification or further review may be requested when necessary.

After completing the review, reviewers must continue to protect manuscript confidentiality and should delete locally retained confidential materials when they are no longer required for authorized editorial purposes.

Suspected violations of reviewer confidentiality, independence, or research integrity requirements may result in reassignment, exclusion of an affected review report, or removal from future reviewing assignments.

9. Ethical Framework and References

These guidelines are informed by internationally recognized standards for scholarly peer review.

  1. COPE, DOAJ, OASPA, and WAME. (2026). Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing, Version 5.0.

  2. Committee on Publication Ethics. Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers.

  3. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. (2026). Responsibilities in the Submission and Peer-Review Process.

  4. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. (2026). Use of AI by Reviewers.

PESSR may periodically review and update these guidelines to maintain consistency with developments in scholarly publishing, research integrity, and ethical peer-review practices.